Nancy Karp + Dancers – piano piano – San Francisco

Amy Lewis in <I>piano piano</I>.<br />© John Hefti. (Click image for larger version)
Amy Lewis in piano piano.
© John Hefti. (Click image for larger version)

Nancy Karp + Dancers
piano piano

Oakland, Dresher Ensemble Studio
27 February 2020

It turns out that the title of Nancy Karp’s newest work is rooted in the Italian language. As relayed in the press materials, the phrase piano piano translates as “slowly, slowly, gradually, gently, carefully; quietly; take your time; don’t rush – you’ll figure it out.” That intention was more than evident in the evening-length work, which premiered Thursday at the Dresher Ensemble Studio in Oakland. Together a cast of six gradually explored the space and gradually explored the music, composed by Jay Cloidt. This exploration was undertaken through lush modern dance, fifty minutes of tonal layers and textures choreographed by Artistic Director Nancy Karp. It’s not often that one gets to experience pure modern dance without a lot of extra stuff – such a treat.

Unfolding over five continuous parts, each set to a different musical selection, piano piano began with great purpose and attention to the word ‘gradual.’ But that didn’t mean that the movement was timid or small, in fact, quite the opposite. Arpeggiated treble notes quivered with expectation and possibility while the ensemble systematically investigated the stage surface with large lunges, parallel attitudes and swinging arms. Extreme pencheés and side extensions entered the vernacular as the music built and intensified. And grand, sweeping circular motions indicated that their exploratory experiment was well underway.

Nol Simonse in piano piano.© John Hefti. (Click image for larger version)
Nol Simonse in piano piano.
© John Hefti. (Click image for larger version)

As dissonant cluster chords took over in Cloidt’s score, the six began ascending up a small staircase and into the balcony space. Clinging to the railings and engaging the walls as partners, they continued their survey unhurried. The collection of notes hovered in delicious ambiguity, neither major nor minor, as the choreography similarly played with what might become a dancing surface. In what was the most beautiful picture of the night, Amy Lewis and Nol Simonse worked together to create a gravity-defying balance in the balcony – she looked as though she was effortlessly floating skyward. Later sections found a plinky piano part meeting with robotic phrases and a clanging bell inspiring clock-type motions.

Striking and pleasurable from beginning to end, piano piano’s choreography, with its spinal curves and diagonal postures, made me smile. Not a trendy inversion in sight; instead, Karp filled the stage with clean modern dance vocabulary – solid lines and uncluttered positions, all flowing seamlessly together. And the communication of the material was so remarkable. piano piano’s cast was made up of some heavy hitters in the San Francisco dance scene (Chris Black, Nick Brentley, Sonsherée Giles, Katie Kruger, Lewis and Simonse) and watching them move was a gift. Accomplished technicians surely, but each also has such deep and enviable artistry.

I think the only miss for me was that most of the music, except for the final chapter, played with phenomenal vivacity by pianist Marja Mutru, was recorded. Not only was the show held in a music rehearsal studio (which suggests acoustical prowess), but with Cloidt’s compositions being so woven into the work, it seemed like a missed opportunity not to have each part scored by live musicians.

About the author

Heather Desaulniers

Heather Desaulniers is a freelance dance writer based in Oakland, California. She is the Editorial Associate and SF/Bay Area columnist for CriticalDance, the dance curator for SF Arts Monthly and a frequent contributor to several dance-focused publications. Website:

DanceTabs Contributors

Regular contributors…

Claudia Bauer | Foteini Christofilopoulou | Gay Morris | Graham Watts | Heather Desaulniers | Jann Parry | Josephine Leask | Karen Greenspan | Lynette Halewood | Marina Harss | Oksana Khadarina | Siobhan Murphy | Susanna Sloat | Valerie Lawson | Bruce Marriott (Ed)

The above list is composed of those whose work we feature regularly and have generally contributed in the last few months.

>> Complete list of DanceTabs Contributors and more info.

DanceTabs Tweets