Mariinsky Ballet – A Tribute to Maya Plisetskaya, Program B – New York

Uliana Lopatkina in <I>The Dying Swan</I>.<br />© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)
Uliana Lopatkina in The Dying Swan.
© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)

Mariinsky Ballet
A Tribute to Maya Plisetskaya
Program B: Russian dance from Swan Lake, Le Spectre de la Rose, Pavlova and Cecchetti, 7th Waltz from Chopiniana, Bluebird Pas de Deux, pas de deux from Scheherazade, pas de deux from The Firebird, pas de deux from Giselle, The Dying Swan

New York, Brooklyn Academy of Music
26 February 2016

Mysterious Mariinsky

What’s going on in the head office at the Mariinsky Ballet? A program like tonight’s, the second of four “Tribute to Maya Plisetskaya” evenings at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, makes you wonder. (The company is concurrently performing Raymonda in Washington, DC.) What was billed as a tribute to the great Bolshoi ballerina, who died last year, turned out to be an unremarkable evening of ballet excerpts, selected with little thought or logic. The connection to Plisetskaya seemed tenuous at best; in fact, the role of Giselle, represented here by pas de deux, was one of the very few in the classical canon that Plisetskaya never danced. The photographs projected onto a scrim before each excerpt were all of other dancers: Anna Pavlova, Vaslav Nijinsky, Enrico Cecchetti.

Uliana Lopatkina in <I>The Dying Swan</I>.<br />© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)
Uliana Lopatkina in The Dying Swan.
© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)

If anything, the evening was more of a tribute to Uliana Lopatkina, possibly the company’s most revered principal dancer, and to the early twentieth-century choreographer Michel Fokine. Tall, majestic, and inscrutable, with an impossibly slender, elongated frame and arms that move with the billowing lightness of smoke, Lopatkina is a superb specimen of that already exquisite species known as the ballerina. She appeared in no less than five excerpts, always with the same remote half-smile and veiled eyes, like a queen on a quick visit from a far-off, and no doubt splendid, kingdom.

The problem is that none of the excerpts seemed to move her in any way. She began with the “Russian dance” from Swan Lake, adapted by Lopatkina herself. The Russian headdress was beautiful, but the steps consisted mainly of delicate bourrées, enigmatic glances, and little heel-toe moves. (The music, performed by the lustrous-sounding Mariinsky Orchestra under the baton of Alexei Repnikov, was admittedly a high point. Bravo to the violin soloist, alas not identified in the program.)

Later, Lopatkina joined Roman Belyakov in a pas de deux by John Neumeier, Pavlova and Cecchetti, a kind of ersatz ballet lesson (set, incongruously to the exquisite entr’acte music from Sleeping Beauty) whose main point seemed to be the display of her magnificent insteps. She returned for the waltz from Michel Fokine’s Chopiniana, danced at a glacial tempo, reverently partnered by the handsome Andrey Ermakov. The pas de deux from Firebird (also by Fokine), was marred by cartoonish acting by Ermakov. His reaction to the offer of the firebird’s magic feather – a wide-eyed stare, as if to say, “my, my, what’s this?” – definitely broke the mood, already fragile. Lopatkina’s remarkably spare, meditative performance of The Dying Swan, which closed the evening, came as a huge relief.

Uliana Lopatkina in The Dying Swan.© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)
Uliana Lopatkina in The Dying Swan.
© Jack Vartoogian. (Click image for larger version)

In between were interspersed other pas de deux, seemingly ad hoc: Fokine’s Art Nouveau-inspired Le Spectre de la Rose, danced by Maria Shirinkina and the usually exemplary Vladimir Shklyarov, looking atypically off his game. The “Bluebird” pas de deux from Sleeping Beauty, also at an exceedingly slow tempo. This, to allow the soloist, Valeria Martinuk, extra time to show her impressive balance and high leg lifts. (But where was the charm?) The sexy pas de deux for Zobéide and the Golden Slave from Fokine’s Sheherazade, never subtle, was an orgy of caresses and exotic poses. And then, out of nowhere, the second act pas de deux from Giselle, impeccably danced by Shklyarov and Shirinkina.

But what’s the point of a program like this, so like that of the many ballet galas that blow through town? The Mariinsky is a storied company; it has produced some of the greatest dancers, and many of the greatest works, in ballet. It deserves better, and so does its New York audience.

About the author

Marina Harss

Marina Harss is a free-lance dance writer and translator in New York. Her dance writing has appeared in the New Yorker, The Nation, Playbill, The Faster Times, DanceView, The Forward, Pointe, and Ballet Review. Her translations, which include Irène Némirovsky’s “The Mirador,” Dino Buzzati’s “Poem Strip,” and Pasolini’s “Stories from the City of God” have been published by FSG, Other Press, and New York Review Books. You can check her updates on Twitter at: @MarinaHarss


  • The program B was NOT dedicated to Plisetskaya, but to Pavlova and Nijinsky. It’s very strange you didn’t know that.

  • Giselle pas de deux wasnt’ impeccable at all, sorry. Shklyarov was very sloppy, he hopped too much, after assemble and after tour en l air, infortunately.

  • Yes, right, Pavlova Checchetti is on music from SB.
    An excerpt from The Firebird was danced exactly as it was staged by Liepa who retored the original choreography several years ago, and the mood of the piece there shouldn’t be fragile at all. Ivan’s character is quite the opposite to the magical, but sly and playful Firebird who pretends to be weak (remember how she ruthlessly destoys the whole Kashei’s kingdom) – he should be real, funny, vivacios, witty. Exactly as he was.

  • Thank you very much for your comments. The entire four-part appearance at BAM was billed as “A Tribute to Maya Plisetskaya” in four parts, ABC&D. I was simply pointing out the strangeness of including a program that has so little to do with Plisetkaya’s legacy. Regarding the dancing, thank goodness we all have our own point of view.

  • In making up the page I think I might have confused things a little by including a picture of the Plisetskaya stage projection image. Although all the bills were a tribute to her I now gather that the stage projection was not used every night and certainly not at the B bill. To avoid any confusion I’ve now replaced with another picture of Lopatkina. BM.

  • Like it is said above, I think that this programme B was dedicated to Pavlova and Nijinsky. The selection of the pieces can certainly be argued but 2 stars out of 5, really? Sure the Mariinsky comes with very high expectations but that’s not a reason. The 5mn of the Dying Swan alone deserved 5 stars that night. I’d travel the world to see someone dance that piece better than she did on Friday (I thought it was better on Friday than Sunday actually). Yes, Lopatkina was the star, not Plisetskaya, but does it matter? Lopatkina is arguably the greatest ballerina of the last 20 years. I’m blessed to see her. Her feet, her hands are so incredible, every move she makes is so gracious, she’s so light and her turns are just unreal, so quick and so flowing. I understand your critic of the programs which were short and could have been more enthralling, yet in my opinion the outstanding talent of Lopatkina that was even more on display on Sunday night (program D) is something to die for.

Click here to post a comment

DanceTabs Contributors

Regular contributors…

Claudia Bauer | Foteini Christofilopoulou | Gay Morris | Graham Watts | Heather Desaulniers | Jann Parry | Josephine Leask | Karen Greenspan | Lynette Halewood | Marina Harss | Oksana Khadarina | Siobhan Murphy | Susanna Sloat | Valerie Lawson | Bruce Marriott (Ed)

The above list is composed of those whose work we feature regularly and have generally contributed in the last few months.

>> Complete list of DanceTabs Contributors and more info.

DanceTabs Tweets