Morphoses/Pontus Lidberg – Within (Labyrinth Within) – New York

Gabrielle Lamb and Jens Weber in <I>Within (Labyrinth Within)</I>.<br />© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)
Gabrielle Lamb and Jens Weber in Within (Labyrinth Within).
© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)

Morphoses/Pontus Lidberg
Within (Labyrinth Within)

New York, Joyce Theater
7 November 2012

Within (Labyrinth Within), a new dance and film work by the Swedish choreographer Pontus Lidberg, begins quietly. Lidberg lies on his side at center stage, his back to the audience. Surrounding him are three red poppies sprouting from the floor. Slowly and softly, he begins to move, rolling over, tracing soft semi-circles with his feet, lifting his arms occasionally into fifth position. He seems, above all, vulnerable and alone.

Four other dancers soon join Lidberg, but even when the stage becomes crowded, a sense of detachment prevails in this complicated hour-long, ballet-inflected piece, which was given its New York premiere by Morphoses at the Joyce Theater last week. In a recurring group passage, for example, the dancers lean against one another or walk under bridges formed by limbs, their steps unfolding to a steady rhythm, but any bonds formed are fleeting. Watching them dance together is like watching water pass through fingers.

Isolation pervades even the partnering. An early pas de deux finds Adrian Danchig-Waring (a soloist with New York City Ballet) and Laura Mead trading passive and aggressive roles, never managing to reach harmonious middle ground. With a quick push, Mead sends Danchig-Waring falling to the floor. He shows no trace of emotion. When Danchig-Waring carries Mead, her body becomes as rigid as a plank. It’s the choreographic equivalent of bickering; although they try to be heard, each might as well be addressing a wall.

The film segments – which are projected onto a large, moveable scrim – figure into in the work in two ways. At first Lidberg allows film and live performance to unfold simultaneously, or jumps quickly between one medium and the other. In the second half, he surrenders to the screen entirely, showing his 2010 film Labyrinth Within. (It was this piece, according to the press release, that inspired Morphoses’ artistic director Lourdes Lopez to invite Lidberg to create this larger work.)

<I>Within (Labyrinth Within)</I> - Jens Weber, Pontus Lidberg, Gabrielle Lamb and Wendy Whelan (seated, in film).<br />© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)
Within (Labyrinth Within) – Jens Weber, Pontus Lidberg, Gabrielle Lamb and Wendy Whelan (seated, in film).
© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)

The former approach – of mixing film and live performance – fares better. Jens Weber and Gabrielle Lamb dance a duet alongside filmed versions of themselves dressed in the same costumes. A framed mirror depicted on screen often reflects their dancing as a real mirror would, but the live performers sometimes break abruptly with their doppelgangers. On screen, Weber balances Lamb on his shoulders as the real-life couple briskly walk offstage. The doubling of performers – and their fragmentation – adds another edge to Lidberg’s meditation on missed connections.

Sometimes the film actors don’t dance at all: While Lidberg performs another floorwork-heavy solo, Wendy Whelan (a New York City Ballet Principal) – wearing a black cocktail dress and high heels – walks on screen, plants herself on a stool, and becomes a spectator. She fidgets occasionally with her hair. (Were it not for Whelan, we might do the same: Lidberg’s solos become duller as they repeat the same material.)

The full-length film, Labyrinth Within, which features Whelan and Giovanni Bucchieri alongside Lidberg, also explores isolation and strained relationships, albeit in more explicit terms. The performers don’t speak, but the film offers a story of sorts. Bucchieri’s character suspects his wife (Whelan) of infidelity – and rightly so: She meets with Lidberg in hidden rooms, tying herself in knots with her partner, while her husband is away.

The mysteries are tantalizing. Is the affair imagined? Does an introductory scene showing two sweaty men groping – their faces obscured – suggest that the husband has secret urges and is jealous of his wife’s fling? The film, however, is ultimately undone by a sappy conclusion and self-conscious chicness: the high-fashion costumes, overly slick production values, and melodramatic score distract from the dancing and make the film seem too often like a perfume commercial.

Liza Voll in <I>Within (Labyrinth Within)</I>.<br />© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)
Liza Voll in Within (Labyrinth Within).
© Christopher Duggan. (Click image for larger version)

These performances marked the end of an era for Morphoses, a company already well acquainted with change. The ensemble was founded jointly by Lopez and Christopher Wheeldon in 2007, and after Wheeldon’s departure three years later it embraced a new model, hosting a different resident artistic director each year to work with the company and choreograph a new work on its dancers. Lopez, who took the helm of Miami City Ballet in September, has stated that Morphoses will follow her there, possibly to become the traditional ballet company’s experimental wing.

Within (Labyrinth Within) is no masterpiece, but it presents exciting possibilities for contemporary ballet while avoiding the hyperextended steps and sexual clichés that muddy so much of the field. If the pieces Lopez brings to her new company are in this vein, Miami will surely benefit from her innovative spirit.

About the author

Ryan Wenzel

Ryan Wenzel is a dance writer and editor in New York. He blogs about ballet, modern, contemporary, and traditional dance at and edits the dance section of The Brooklyn Rail, a monthly journal of arts, culture, and politics. He has written about topics other than dance for publications including The Advocate, Details, Popular Photography, and American Photo. You can find him on Twitter at @BodiesNeverLie.

DanceTabs Contributors

Regular contributors…

Claudia Bauer | Foteini Christofilopoulou | Gay Morris | Graham Watts | Heather Desaulniers | Jann Parry | Josephine Leask | Karen Greenspan | Lynette Halewood | Marina Harss | Oksana Khadarina | Siobhan Murphy | Susanna Sloat | Valerie Lawson | Bruce Marriott (Ed)

The above list is composed of those whose work we feature regularly and have generally contributed in the last few months.

>> Complete list of DanceTabs Contributors and more info.

DanceTabs Tweets